courtesy of Douglas Elliman
- The Alexander brothers have been hit with federal sex-trafficking charges.
- Oren and Tal Alexander are top real-estate agents. Police also arrested a third brother.
- The brothers earlier denied the accusations through an attorney.
The Alexander brothers were arrested on Wednesday on federal charges of sex trafficking. Prosecutors accused the siblings of operating a “long-running sex trafficking scheme,” according to an unsealed indictment.
The New York prosecutors said in the indictment that Tal and Oren — who are among the nation’s top luxury real-estate agents — and their brother, Alon, collaborated for more than a decade with others both “known and unknown” to “repeatedly and violently drug, sexually assault, and rape dozens of victims.”
The indictment said the brothers used their wealth and prominent positions “to create opportunities to rape and sexually assault women” in Manhattan and Miami in a scheme that began in 2010 and lasted more than 10 years.
At times, prosecutors said the brothers planned out the sexual assaults in advance “using the promise of luxury experiences, travel, and accommodations to lure and entice women to locations where they were forcibly raped or sexually assaulted, sometimes by multiple men, including one or more of the Alexander brothers.”
Other times, the Alexander brothers chose their victims by chance, prosecutors said.
The real-estate duo, in particular, the indictment said, “used their prominent positions in the industry to induce other women to attend events and parties, and to meet other women at those events and parties, whom one or more of the defendants later sexually assaulted.”
Prosecutors alleged the Alexander brothers worked together and with other men to arrange events and both domestic and international trips that they used as “bait” to “recruit, entice, harbor, transport, and maintain multiple women.”
Ahead of events and trips, the Alexander brothers would secure drugs, including hallucinogenic mushrooms, cocaine, and GHB, which they agreed to provide women, the indictment says.
On multiple occasions, they and others would “surreptitiously” drug women’s drinks, prosecutors said.
“At times, the defendants physically restrained and held down their victims during the rapes and sexual assaults and ignored screams and explicit requests to stop,” the indictment said.
Oren Alexander, Alon Alexander, and their cousin, Ohad Fisherman, were also separately charged in Florida with sexual battery in three incidents in Miami involving three different women in 2016, 2017, and 2021.
Katherine Fernandez Rundle, the state attorney for Miami-Dade County in Florida, announced the charges in a joint news conference with the Miami Beach police department on Wednesday.
Florida prosecutors charged Oren Alexander with three counts of sexual battery, with one of the charges involving multiple perpetrators and classified as a second-degree felony. Alon Alexander was charged with one count of sexual battery involving multiple perpetrators, a second-degree felony. Fisherman was charged with one count of sexual battery by multiple perpetrators.
In the first incident in 2016, Oren and Alon took turns raping a woman at Alon’s Miami Beach apartment while Fisherman held her down, the state attorney said. The woman told police that after the assault, Oren asked her to shower and Alon told her not to tell anybody what had happened. The woman told her two sisters and a friend about the assault but did not contact police at the time because she feared retribution from the men, the state attorney said.
Prosecutors said the second incident, which involved only Oren, took place after a woman attended a real-estate event with him in 2017. After the event, Oren invited her to his apartment, where he gave her a glass of wine, after which she said she felt weak and out of control of her body. She found herself on Oren’s bed with Oren on top of her; she could not move or speak or push him off. He then raped her, she said.
In the third incident in 2021, a woman met Oren at a dinner she attended with a friend, the state attorney said. Oren invited the woman and her friend to his house on Flamingo Drive. At his house, Oren brought the woman to a couch next to his bedroom, removed her shoes, and started kissing her. The woman said she felt uncomfortable as Oren became aggressive. When she tried to pull away from him, he ripped off the top of her dress, leaving her naked on top. She went to his bedroom to grab a T-shirt from his closet and tried to leave the house. But when she got downstairs, she realized she could not leave because the doors were remote-controlled. She went back upstairs to ask Oren to let her out. There, Oren pushed her onto his bed, held her down with his knees, and assaulted her as she told him no, prosecutors said.
Rundle, the state attorney, thanked the “brave women” for disclosing what happened to them.
“These women are strong and they’re resilient,” she said. “They are an example to anyone else out there who has experienced sex violence.”
Local news footage showed Oren and Alon being escorted into the Turner Guilford Knight Correctional Center in Miami on Wednesday. Tal, who was not mentioned in the Florida news conference, was being held at a separate jail, Local 10 News reported.
The brothers’ arrest follows years of sexual-assault allegations by multiple women.
Deanna Paul, a New York attorney for Tal Alexander, confirmed to Business Insider that police arrested the brothers in Miami on Wednesday morning but declined to comment further.
The brothers have “strongly” denied any wrongdoing, James Cinque, a New York-based attorney, told Business Insider in September.
“We have asked them not to comment while these matters work their way through the legal system,” Cinque said, “but are comfortable that they will ultimately be vindicated.”
The FBI began investigating the Alexander brothers after The Real Deal first reported in June that two women had filed civil lawsuits against Oren and Alon earlier this year.
The women, Kate Whiteman and Rebecca Mandel, said the brothers took turns raping them in two separate incidents in 2010 and 2012, respectively. About 10 days after The Real Deal’s article was published, another woman, Angelica Parker, filed a lawsuit accusing Alon and Tal of raping her in their New York City apartment in 2012 while Oren watched. In July, a fourth woman, the actor and comedian Renée Willett, filed a lawsuit against Oren, accusing him of drugging and raping her, also in his SoHo apartment in 2015.
“We are glad to hear that there will finally be some measure of accountability for the Alexander brothers and justice for their many victims,” David E. Gottlieb, a partner at Wigdor, the law firm representing Parker, said in a statement to BI. “We applaud all the survivors who have had the strength and courage to speak up about their unimaginable experiences after years of pain and suffering.”
A day after the criminal indictments, another woman, going by “Jane Doe,” filed a lawsuit in New York against Alon and Oren, accusing them both of raping her in 2016.
The lawsuit said Alon invited the plaintiff to a barbecue and pool party in Miami on New Year’s Eve but that when she arrived she realized she was the only guest. She said Fisherman held her down while Oren raped her with Alon watching. Alon then raped her, the lawsuit said.
Lawyers for Alon, Oren, and Fisherman did not respond to a request for comment from BI on the new lawsuit.
Alon and Oren also appeared in court in Miami on Thursday, where a judge ordered they be held without bond, The New York Times reported. Alon had told the judge his wife was expected to give birth to their first child “any day now” and that she was counting on him to be with her. The next hearing is set for Friday.
At a press conference on Wednesday announcing the indictment, Damian Williams, the US attorney for the Southern District of New York, called on additional victims to speak out.
“Our investigation is far from over,” Williams said. “If you have been a victim of the alleged sexual violence perpetrated by Alon Alexander, Oren Alexander, or Tal Alexander — or if you know anything about their alleged crimes — we urge you to come forward.”
Since June, more than a dozen women have said they were raped or assaulted by the three brothers, sometimes in tandem. Business Insider spoke to four women who described being assaulted or feeling coerced into sexual encounters, including one who said Tal, now 38, raped her in Las Vegas in 2017.
Business Insider’s investigation found that it was an open secret in wealthy social circles for years that the Alexander twins, 37, and their older brother Tal, mistreated women.
Oren and Tal started their real-estate careers at Douglas Elliman before launching their own brokerage, Official, in 2022. Alon works for the family’s security company in Florida.
December 12, 2024: This story has been updated to include a new lawsuit that was filed a day after the criminal indictments as well as Alon and Oren’s court appearance on Thursday.
